How My Understanding of a “Good Choir Sound” Has Changed Since I First Started Conducting Children

When I think back to my first years of working with a children's choir, my understanding of a “good sound” was much simpler than it is today.

Naturally, I listened first for the most obvious things: Was the pitch accurate? Was the rhythm together? Were the children producing enough sound?

Those things still matter. But as I gained more experience working with young singers, I began to realise that the moment a choir starts to sound more mature is not necessarily when everyone sings louder, or even when every individual child gets their own notes right.

It is often when the children begin to hear one another.

Choir is unusual in that every singer must produce their own voice, yet the final goal cannot be for everyone to listen only to themselves.

A child may sing their own melodic line accurately, but if they are unaware of the voices beside them, the overall tone, the breathing or the direction of the phrase, they are still functioning largely as an individual singer inside a group.

They have not yet fully become part of an ensemble.

Over the years, this has made me place much more emphasis on listening.

I listen for whether a child is simply trying to make their own voice heard, or whether they are beginning to adjust in response to the people around them. Blend, to me, is not simply a matter of telling everyone to “sing more softly”.

Real blend begins when singers become aware of how their individual sound fits into a larger whole.

I have also become much more particular about diction.

In a children's choir, the timing of a consonant or the release of a final sound may seem like a very small detail. But when many children sing together, tiny differences in timing can immediately affect rhythmic clarity, text and ensemble precision.

There are moments in rehearsal when we may repeat a single word many times.

Not because the word itself is unusually difficult, but because exercises like these help children experience something important: their sound does not exist in isolation.

If one consonant arrives slightly early or slightly late, the sound of the whole group changes.

Moving Beyond Singing the Right Notes

Another area that has changed significantly in my teaching is the way I approach phrasing.

Earlier on, it was easy to focus first on instructions such as: breathe here, crescendo there, sing this line more softly.

Those directions are still useful. But over time, I have become more interested in whether a child understands a deeper question:

Where is this musical sentence going?

If students simply memorise a collection of breathing points and dynamic markings, music can easily become a list of instructions to follow.

A phrase begins to feel more complete when children start to sense its direction. Breath, dynamics, text and tone stop functioning as separate tasks and begin working together towards a musical idea.

This has also made me much more careful about repertoire selection.

When I first encounter a beautiful or exciting piece, it is easy to be attracted to the work itself. Today, I ask more questions.

Is this piece appropriate for the children in front of me right now?

Does it suit their vocal range, language ability, current sound, harmony experience and the amount of rehearsal time we realistically have?

A good piece of music is not automatically the right piece for every ensemble at every stage.

If the difficulty is far beyond what the singers can currently manage, much of their attention will be spent simply trying to “get the notes out”.

That leaves far less mental space for listening, diction, tone, phrasing and genuine musical expression.

For that reason, I increasingly see repertoire selection itself as part of vocal and ensemble training.

Appropriate does not mean easy.

Children still need challenge. But ideally, the challenge sits just beyond what they can currently do — close enough that sustained practice can genuinely bring them there.

A “Good Sound” Is Not One Fixed Sound

The longer I conduct, the less interested I become in treating a “good choir sound” as a single fixed template.

Children's choir is not about training dozens of children to sound as though they are one identical person.

For me, it is closer to helping every singer understand how their own voice exists within a shared sound.

They gradually learn to breathe together, listen together and shape a phrase together. They learn when their sound needs greater clarity and when it needs to return into the ensemble.

That is also why I no longer judge the success of a rehearsal only by asking:

“Did it sound good today?”

I listen for other things.

Are the children hearing one another more than they did before?

Does a musical sentence have a clearer direction?

Are consonants that used to scatter beginning to arrive together?

Are the singers becoming more aware that every sound they make affects the people beside them?

These changes can be very small.

To an audience, the difference may last only a few seconds. But the teacher and the children often know how many repetitions, rehearsals and weeks of work sit behind those few seconds.

This is also why some of my most satisfying moments as a teacher do not happen when a prize is announced.

Competition results can certainly be meaningful, and performance gives children valuable goals and experiences. But the moments that stay with me most often happen quietly in the rehearsal room — when something we have worked on for a long time suddenly begins to make sense.

The children hear it.

They understand it.

And finally, they do it.

Perhaps Choir Is Training More Than Sound

Looking back, I increasingly feel that choral education ultimately develops more than singing.

A child needs to express their own voice while learning to hear others. They need to take responsibility for their own part while understanding that they belong to something larger.

There is something valuable in that process.

To retain your own voice, while learning how to build something together with other people.

So if someone asks me today what creates a good children's choir sound, I would still talk about pitch, tone, diction, phrasing and technique.

All of those things matter.

But perhaps the clearest sign that an ensemble is beginning to grow is when the children's attention slowly moves from:

“Am I singing this correctly?”

towards:

“Are we doing this together?”

A mature choral sound is not simply many people singing at the same time.

It begins when many people truly start singing together.

About the Author

Chris Lai
Arts Educator | Founder & Principal of Tone Color Academy

Chris works across children's music, choral and multidisciplinary arts education. His writing brings together classroom practice, conducting, educational leadership, reading and ongoing reflection on how children learn through the arts.

Explore Music Learning at Tone Color Academy

For children and young people who are interested in singing, ensemble work and developing a more sensitive musical ear, Tone Color Academy offers several pathways that complement the ideas explored in this article.

Children's Choir Class
A group singing experience that develops pitch, harmony, diction, musical expression and ensemble awareness while helping children learn to listen and perform together.
→ Explore Children's Choir Class

Aural Training Class
Focused listening activities that develop pitch recognition, rhythmic accuracy, musical memory, phrasing and responsiveness — skills that support both singers and instrumentalists.
→ Explore Aural Training Class

Classical Vocal Class
Structured individual vocal training in breath, tone production, diction, expression and repertoire, supporting the development of a healthy and confident singing voice.
→ Explore Classical Vocal Class

Tone Color Academy is based in South Puchong and provides music and multidisciplinary arts education for children and young people, serving families from Puchong, Putrajaya, Cyberjaya, Seri Kembangan and surrounding communities.

→ Explore Tone Color Academy Music Classes